Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Description of your first forum.

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by Bill Limoge » Thu, 20 Mar 1997 04:00:00



I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find any in
stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights that I used to turn on
when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  Has anyone ever used one around plants
??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that it would appear
that one would do the work of three fluorescent gro-bulbs, and at a
fraction of the cost.  I'll bet that it would make some of the brighter
flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.

Any ideas ???

Bill Limoges

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by Mark & Victor » Thu, 20 Mar 1997 04:00:00



Quote:

>I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find any in
>stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights that I used to
turn on
>when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  Has anyone ever used one around
plants
>??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that it would
appear
>that one would do the work of three fluorescent gro-bulbs, and at a
>fraction of the cost.  I'll bet that it would make some of the
brighter
>flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.

>Any ideas ???

>Bill Limoges

If it is not a full spectrum  light, you will not get good results.  I
use cool bulbs to start seedlings, but if I was growing plants indoors,
I would need to switch to a fuller spectrum  light source.  Most
tropical fish stores will sell full spectrum bulbs, at about 5 dollars
each.

Victoria

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by bgrevem » Thu, 20 Mar 1997 04:00:00


Quote:

> =
> I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find =
> any in stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights =
> that I used to turn on when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  =
> Has anyone ever used one around plants
> ??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that =
> it would appear that one would do the work of three =
> fluorescent gro-bulbs, and at a fraction of the cost.  =
> I'll bet that it would make some of the brighter
> flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.
> =
> Any ideas ???
> =
> Bill Limoges

Hi Bill.

This is a basic primer on lights that I wrote a while
ago.  I don't think that you would get a great deal
more total light (visible and invisible) out of your
black light, but you might due to not having to go
through the fluorescent stage.  However, you would =

lose some light in the filter that takes out the =

visible light.  The major question to ask is if your
plants "like" the ultra violet spectrum.

Cheers
   Bryce

There basically two types of lights in use today.
"Regular" or incandescent lamps AND fluorescent =

lamps.

Regular INCANDESCENT light bulbs work, by passing =

    electric current through a wire or "filament" =

    which gets so hot that it produces light in =

    the visible range.  It produces a more or less =

    continuous spectrum of light.  Only about =

    5 percent of the electric energy is given off
    as light.  The rest is given off as heat.
    The filament is surrounded by a vacuum which =

    prevents oxygen from reacting with the =

    hot filament and burning it up.

    HALOGEN lamps are a subset of incandescent =

    lamps.  In a regular vacuum filled lamp, =

    molecules of the filament (which is white hot), =

    are continually being boiled off the surface, =

    and deposited on the inside of the glass =

    envelope, which is why light bulbs that have =

    been in service for a long time have a dark, =

    or black "mirrored" look.  =

    Bulbs that are filled with inert Halogen gas, =

    have a gas pressure that forces most of those
    molecules back on the filament.  Thus the
    bulbs tend to have a constant light over =

    their life time.  They also tend to be =

    "whiter".

    However, Halogen lights are an incandescent =

    light.  They have a filament, and their =

    efficiency is in the same range with other =

    incandescent lights.  i.e. around 5%.

FLUORESCENT bulbs start out with electric current =

    through a mercury vapor.  This e***s the =

    electrons of the Mercury atoms, and they move =

    (temporarily) to a higher energy orbital shell.  =

    When they move back, they release photons of =

    light.  This light is mostly in the invisible =

    ultra violet range.  As this light moves out, =

    it hits the florescent powder coating on the =

    inside of the tube.  This powder absorbs the =

    photons and then fluoresces, releasing light =

    in the visible range.  There are three basic =

    powders used.  There is a red, a green, and a =

    blue.  Each fluoresces at it=92s own particular =

    wavelength.  The tube manufacture mixes the =

    powders to get what ever color he wants.  The =

    good news is that the efficiency is much higher.  =

    I believe that something on the order of 25 percent
    of the energy is converted into light.  This =

    means that for a given amount of watts, you get
    about 5 times the light, or for a given amount =

    of light, it takes 20% of the power, and you
    get only 15% of the heat.  That's why they are
    called "cool" lights

    The catch of course is, that although the light =

    may look a given color, it is still made up of =

    only the three colors.  It is not a continuous =

    spectrum.  This is why you can=92t tell true colors =

    under fluorescent light.  =

    Black lights are lamps (usually mercury vapor =

    type lights) that have a filter that removes almost =

    all of the visible light.  The fluorescent =

    powder that is normally on the inside of the tube
    is painted on to neat posters and stuff and glows =

    brightly.

GROW-LUX / VITA LIGHT
    While incandescent bulbs have a continuous =

    spectrum, they are heavily weighted toward the =

    red end, with almost nothing in the blue region.  =

    Incandescent GROW-LUX tries to correct this by
    putting a filter on the lamp that absorbs (and =

    convert to heat) a portion of the red light,
    giving you a more balanced spectrum.  Less light =

    over all, but more balanced.

    It is my understanding that with fluorescent =

    GROW-LUX they have tried to balance the three =

    colors to look like the light from the =

    incandescent GROW-LUX  However, by definition,
    all fluorescent based lights have a non =

    continuous spectrum.

SUN LIGHT
    If you are trying to match the suns light, the =

    best way is with a mixture of incandescent bulbs =

    to give you a spread of the light spectrum, and =

    fluorescent lights to balance out the blue end.

That still leaves a bunch of questions.

How important the "correct" spectrum is to plants?

What is the "correct" spectrum? =

Do plants want/require a continuous spectrum =

matching the Suns light?

Do plants want/require a specific wavelength, or a =

specific combination of wavelengths?

Do all plants want/require the SAME wavelengths?

What to plants "do" with the wavelengths that they =

don't "want"?

Can they "use" wavelengths that they don't "like"
if they have to?

And of course, the biggie;
If there is a benefit to using GROW-LUX/VITA-LIGHT =

is it worth the extra expense?

-- =

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
| Bryce Grevemeyer        | Phone:    (313) 845-5589      |
| Ford ETC C370           | FAX:      (313) 845 3799      |

| Dearborn, MI 48121-6010 | Ford PROFS: IBMMAIL(I1483006) |
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by s.. » Thu, 20 Mar 1997 04:00:00


Quote:
> >I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find any in
> >stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights that I used to turn on
> >when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  Has anyone ever used one around plants
> >??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that it would appear
> >that one would do the work of three fluorescent gro-bulbs, and at a
> >fraction of the cost.  I'll bet that it would make some of the brighter
> >flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.

> >Any ideas ???

> >Bill Limoges

If the blacklight is (as we are all assumimg) high in the UV range (only)
it will be more of a detriment than a help.  Plants need (and this is a
simplification) a pretty broad spectrum of light to grow well. There is
some research that indicate flowering plants need a somewhat more red
range (of visible light, not infra red) than just foliage ones.

Bill & Harvey
SKID  zone 6  CT  USA

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by Polly M. La » Thu, 20 Mar 1997 04:00:00


Quote:

> > >I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find any in
> > >stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights that I used to turn on
> > >when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  Has anyone ever used one around plants
> > >??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that it would appear
> > >that one would do the work of three fluorescent gro-bulbs, and at a
> > >fraction of the cost.  I'll bet that it would make some of the brighter
> > >flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.

> > >Any ideas ???

> > >Bill Limoges

Greenhouse glass filters out some if not all UV, doesn't it? If so, the
plants do fine without the UV using only the visible wavwlegnths. I
would also assume that some plants would suffer cell damage similar to
what we do from too much UV exposure.
 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by Brian Krusch » Fri, 21 Mar 1997 04:00:00


(Bill writes)

Quote:
>>I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find any in
>>stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights that I used to
>turn on
>>when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  Has anyone ever used one around
>plants
>>??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that it would
>appear
Brian writes... Uhh, bill, you can't see UV light, it is beyond the normal

spectrum of vision.. just thought you might like to know:)

Quote:
>>flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.

(victoria writes)

Quote:
>If it is not a full spectrum  light, you will not get good results.  I
>use cool bulbs to start seedlings, but if I was growing plants indoors,
>I would need to switch to a fuller spectrum  light source.  Most
>tropical fish stores will sell full spectrum bulbs, at about 5 dollars
>each.

Brian writes.. I go along with Victoria on this one, I can't say anything
about starting seedlings, but the  "grow-lux" lamps are specially made to
produce more intense light in the frequencies that plants need to
synthesize food.  A broad spectrum light puts out all frequencies of light
in all wave lengths, while the grow-lux lamps put out more intense light
in the frequencies that the plant uses, so they would be better for a
green leafed plant.  If you can, get a chart (sometimes comes with the
gro-lux lamps) showing how they work, it's very interesting..

..brian...
--
Standard Disclaimer Applies... Blah Blah Blah...
"It ain't bragging if you can back it up" Jaco Pastorius...

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by Bill Limoge » Fri, 21 Mar 1997 04:00:00



Quote:
> If the blacklight is (as we are all assumimg) high in the UV range (only)
> it will be more of a detriment than a help.  Plants need (and this is a
> simplification) a pretty broad spectrum of light to grow well. There is
> some research that indicate flowering plants need a somewhat more red
> range (of visible light, not infra red) than just foliage ones.

Well, I purchased the blacklight, experimenter that  I am , and am going to
try it, along with regular
fluorescent lighting .  the black light bulb will be suspended from a steel
bracket approximately 3' away from
the plants.  I will be keeping close tabs on the plants development. If you
never hear from me again, you will know that the experiment was too
successful, and I was eaten alive. Perhaps I should get a fan to blow the
UV rays around the greenhouse (haha just kidding ;-p ) I totally agree w/
the broad spectum, this is why I will be supplimenting the Black light w/
the fluorescent lights. Pray for me. ;-)

Bill Limoges

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by Robert Be » Sat, 22 Mar 1997 04:00:00



Quote:

>> > >I was out looking for some gro-lights today, and couldn't find any in
>> > >stock. I did, however, see one of those blacklights that I used to turn on
>> > >when I smoked dope as a ***ager.  Has anyone ever used one around plants
>> > >??  They seem to have a lot of UV light, so much so that it would appear
>> > >that one would do the work of three fluorescent gro-bulbs, and at a
>> > >fraction of the cost.  I'll bet that it would make some of the brighter
>> > >flowers, like the Tropicana rose glow like mad.

>> > >Any ideas ???

>> > >Bill Limoges

First - there are two types of UV radiation, long-wave and short-wave.
The type of black lights you buy to make posters fluoresce is long-wave.
Short-wave UV is the kind that gives you a sunburn, and you generally
can't just buy them.  They do make them, for use in tanning salons.  It's
dangerous, can cause eye damage, and give you a sunburn.  It would do the
same to plants  The long-wave UV tubes do nothing to you, and they will do
nothing to/for plants.

Plants don't need UV to grow.  They use mainly the red and blue parts of
the spectrum.  UV is something they protect themselves against, and a
plant that's getting "sunburned" is not a pretty sight.

Some plants do react to UV by producing pigments, Venus flytrap comes to
mind.  But it also produces that pigment under high intensity light in a
greenhouse, so I suspect that UV isn't the sole factor.

bob
--

------------------------------------------------------------------------  
 Safe upon the solid rock the ugly houses stand:     | Edna St.  
 Come and see my shining palace built upon the sand! | Vincent Millay

 
 
 

Black light in lieu of gro-lights ??

Post by AVarela0 » Sun, 23 Mar 1997 04:00:00


I set up a light Garden for seed-starting for the first time this spring.
I'm using regular fluorescent lights instead of grow lights, and I'm
getting some very happy, vigorous plants. Try using one warm white and one
cool white (assuming you have a light fixture that accomodates two bulbs.)

Happy Gardening!
- Anna V. in Zone 7