Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Description of your first forum.

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Byron &/or Linda Leight » Thu, 01 Aug 1996 04:00:00



A couple of months ago we discovered that our koi LOVE worms.  It
started. of course, by coming across a worm & tossing it in to see what
would happen.  Well, we've gotten them ***ed, I think.  We've
cleaned out our entire yard (approx. 1 acre) of all worms.  Can't find
anymore.  Even have gone so far as to buy fishing worms 2 or 3 times.

Problem:  we're out of worms.  I presume it's ok for them to eat them
most every day since that's one of the things they'd eat in a natural
area.  My question is, does anyone have any experience on growing a
worm farm?  We can't continue to pay $2.50 a day for about 12 worms.

How about other things?  My husband has suggested raw hamburger or
chicken...like just keep a little out from whatever we're making for
dinner that nite.  Kinda worries me tho, they won't find those things
in a natural pond, might not be good for them.  Ideas?

Linda

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Robert Ar » Sat, 03 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Hello!

Here's a few suggestions that may be better and cheaper than those meats:
 Even though koi are omnivorous, they do favor certain things.  Try leafy
green lettuce (Romaine), Lemons and oranges cut into wedges, shrimp or
krill (kind of expensive, tho), Cheerios (good cold weather food - high
in carbos - low in protein), raw spinach leaves (cut off the stems),
shredded raw zuccini, wheat bread, cooked white rice, cooked pasta, -
don't forget regular commercial koi pellets.

Some folks feed watermellon; but I have heard that it can cause some
gastro-intestinal problems.  A big favorite at our place is cooked barley.
  You might check with KOIUSA magazine - they sometimes publish recipes
for home-made koi-chow.

Bon apetite!

Koiboy

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by BOB DENT » Sat, 03 Aug 1996 04:00:00


B&>A couple of months ago we discovered that our koi LOVE worms.  It
B&>started. of course, by coming across a worm & tossing it in to see
B&>what would happen.  Well, we've gotten them ***ed, I think.  We've
B&>cleaned out our entire yard (approx. 1 acre) of all worms.  Can't
B&>find anymore.  Even have gone so far as to buy fishing worms 2 or 3
B&>times.

B&>Problem:  we're out of worms.  I presume it's ok for them to eat them
B&>most every day since that's one of the things they'd eat in a natural
B&>area.  My question is, does anyone have any experience on growing a
B&>worm farm?  We can't continue to pay $2.50 a day for about 12 worms.

B&>How about other things?  My husband has suggested raw hamburger or
B&>chicken...like just keep a little out from whatever we're making for
B&>dinner that nite.  Kinda worries me tho, they won't find those things
B&>in a natural pond, might not be good for them.  Ideas?

Linda,

The alt.aquaria and rec.aquaria subgroups have a FAQ on live food that
you should check out.  It includes a piece on growing your own worms in
a box in the ba***t filled with peat moss and utilizing an occasional
sprinkling of water and of corn meal (worm food).   It is apparently
relatively easy to get a self-sustaining culture of red wrigglers going.

If you're not into culturing them, check the want ads in the back of
Organic Gardening magazine.  Red wrigglers are sold mail order in lots
of a thousand for around $20 as I recollect.  BUT I also recollect they
don't ship them in the summer.

Regards,
Bob D.
---
 CMPQwk #1.42 UNREGISTERED EVALUATION COPY

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Alan Farm » Sun, 04 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:
>B&>How about other things?  

 It includes a piece on growing your own worms in

Quote:
>a box in the ba***t filled with peat moss and utilizing an occasional
>sprinkling of water and of corn meal (worm food).   It is apparently
>relatively easy to get a self-sustaining culture of red wrigglers going.

This will work even outside.Find a good shady spot under a tree.If you can
find a sturdy shipping crate approx 2'x3'x24" filled with potting soil or
compost.(another alternative is a compost pile)Once they're there they
pretty much take care of themselves.Just throw some organic mattter in from
(apple peels, lettuce ect) time to time.

If you're more adventurous,when I was little,I'd go out to my uncles barn
and dig in the manure pile for fishing worms.Always in supply there. :-)

Here in Ga, we have a wkly pub called the farmers and comsumers market
bulletin.Its free from the state and has items grown in Ga for sale. Even
worms.Check with your state agriculture dept and see.

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Eri » Sun, 04 Aug 1996 04:00:00




Quote:
>A couple of months ago we discovered that our koi LOVE worms.  It
>started. of course, by coming across a worm & tossing it in to see what
>would happen.  Well, we've gotten them ***ed, I think.  We've
>cleaned out our entire yard (approx. 1 acre) of all worms.  Can't find
>anymore.  Even have gone so far as to buy fishing worms 2 or 3 times.

>Problem:  we're out of worms.  I presume it's ok for them to eat them
>most every day since that's one of the things they'd eat in a natural
>area.  My question is, does anyone have any experience on growing a
>worm farm?  We can't continue to pay $2.50 a day for about 12 worms.

>How about other things?  My husband has suggested raw hamburger or
>chicken...like just keep a little out from whatever we're making for
>dinner that nite.  Kinda worries me tho, they won't find those things
>in a natural pond, might not be good for them.  Ideas?

>Linda

Well, worms is good, chicken is not, raw hamburger is BAD.
I can?t belive that you?ve used up all the worms on a 1 acre
area, there should be millions of them. Look for worms at night,
but be quick, they?re very sensitive for light, and usally flies
down very fast. It?s not hard to breed them either, a big bucket,
a box or anything that can hold damp soil and worms will do.
Sprinkle _very_ lightly with cornmeal on the soil a couple of
times a week. Remember that this "farm" needs oxygen, and produce
heat, so it got to be wellventilated, and in a cool place.
Worms do produce a lot of eggs, but they have to be somthing around
3 months old to do that, so don?t overharvest in the beginning.
If you only want a dozen worms a day, a three gallon "farm"
will be more then enaugh, but if they?re so expensive where
you live, why don?t you make some easy money?
Don?t feed koi with mammals and things with a lot of fat.

        Good luck!

                        Erik

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Kellie Snide » Sun, 04 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:

> B&>A couple of months ago we discovered that our koi LOVE worms.  It
> B&>started. of course, by coming across a worm & tossing it in to see
> B&>what would happen.  Well, we've gotten them ***ed, I think.  We've
> B&>cleaned out our entire yard (approx. 1 acre) of all worms.

Don't take too many from your yard!  They are essential for good soil
health.

Kellie

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Paul L » Mon, 05 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:

> Don't take too many from your yard!  They are essential for good soil
> health.
> Don't worry, Kellie:

For as much as digging to collect them by human hands, you are
actually helping them by turning the soil arround so that they
can move easier.

I don't think the statement "running out of worm in the yard"
is ever correct. It's like "getting rid of fire ant with
chemical". You can go as far as trashing your lawn, both of
those creature are still there. Unless you remove three
feet of soil all over your yard at once.

As far as feeding the fish. Cricket, roaches ... etc. Just
NOT the fire ant - they will kill your fish inside of them.

Paul

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by johanna stephens » Mon, 05 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:
>As far as feeding the fish. Cricket, roaches ... etc. Just
>NOT the fire ant - they will kill your fish inside of them.

>Paul

- I agree. I fed my newly released frogs a little till they get setteled
in, and I have to be careful to get the crickets on the lilly pads or the
fish gobble them right up. If the frogs are not quick enough the fish just
slide up on the pads and*** their lips!-
Johanna Stephenson
 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Crunch5 » Sun, 18 Aug 1996 04:00:00


I just completed a course at the University of Georgia School of
Veterinary medicine entitled "Fish Health Management".  The instructor was
Dr. John Gratzek noted author and researcher.  Dr. Gratzek said that
Garden worms and raw meat contain parasites that can be transmitted to
your fish, therefore "DO NOT FEED WORMS TO FISH".  I have been feeding
worms to my fish & they love them but according to Dr. Gratzek it will
only be a matter of time until some parasites are transmitted.  I am not
going to feed worms any more.  If my fish do get parasites it will not be
from a food source that I can control.  Dr. Gratzek also recommended NOT
feeding tubifex worms (fresh of freeze dried) to tropical fish for the
same reason.  The worms come from polluted areas and also contain
parasites or their eggs.  The next time you have an opportunity to see
tubifex worms try smelling them.  They stink from all the decaying
material they grow in.

Good Luck
Bob

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Jack Konrat » Mon, 19 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:

> I just completed a course at the University of Georgia School of
> Veterinary medicine entitled "Fish Health Management".  The instructor was
> Dr. John Gratzek noted author and researcher.  Dr. Gratzek said that
> garden worms and raw meat contain parasites that can be transmitted to
> your fish, therefore "DO NOT FEED WORMS TO FISH".  I have been feeding
> worms to my fish & they love them but according to Dr. Gratzek it will
> only be a matter of time until some parasites are transmitted.  I am not
> going to feed worms any more.  If my fish do get parasites it will not be
> from a food source that I can control.  Dr. Gratzek also recommended NOT
> feeding tubifex worms (fresh of freeze dried) to tropical fish for the
> same reason.  The worms come from polluted areas and also contain
> parasites or their eggs.  The next time you have an opportunity to see
> tubifex worms try smelling them.  They stink from all the decaying
> material they grow in.

> Good Luck
> Bob

When I built my first pond, I had an albino catfish that loved worms and
slugs. She was about 3" long when I first bought her, and grew to 9" in one
year on this diet... mostly redworms from the mulch pile and a few slugs now
and then. She died quite suddenly, causing me great concern for the other
fish, all Koi. They never seemed to figure out that the worms were food until
they hit the bottom of the pond, where they were quickly eaten by the
catfish. None of the other fish ever became ill. This worm feeding was the
only thing different about the catfish vs Koi diet. It may be an
unscientific conclusion, but I just don't take any chances with this anymore,
and stick to the pellets... and then only when I want to observe the fish.
The rest of the time they're on their own.

Jack Konrath

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Paul L » Tue, 20 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:

> Path: atglab.bls.com!cssun.mathcs.emory.edu!nntp.msstate.edu!willis.cis.uab.edu!maze.dpo.uab.edu!info.uah.edu!news.msfc.nasa.gov!newsfeed.internetmci.com!news.inc.net!news.sol.net!newspump.sol.net!nntp04.primenet.com!nntp.primenet.com!ddsw1!news.mcs.net!in-news.erinet.com!bug.rahul.net!rahul.net!a2i!hustle.rahul.net!rahul.net!a2i!news.sj-coop.net!news

> Newsgroups: rec.ponds
> Subject: Re: Foods Koi Eat - What's go
> Date: Sun, 18 Aug 1996 13:32:56 -0700
> Organization: Global Electronics
> Lines: 33


> > I just completed a course at the University of Georgia School of
> > Veterinary medicine entitled "Fish Health Management".  The instructor was
> > Dr. John Gratzek noted author and researcher.  Dr. Gratzek said that
> > garden worms and raw meat contain parasites that can be transmitted to
> > your fish, therefore "DO NOT FEED WORMS TO FISH".  I have been feeding
> > worms to my fish & they love them but according to Dr. Gratzek it will
> > only be a matter of time until some parasites are transmitted

In my ponds, the good looking Kois stay in the EPDM lined pond. They eat
expensive Koi food, my plants and todpoles. They grow 3"~4" each year.
In the clay pond, the not so good looking Kois and Comets dig into the
clay, they eat earth worm, bird waste and whatever the nature feed them.
Thye grow 5"~6" each year.

Actually, the good looking fishes have higher chance being screwed by
those artifitial food.

Of course, if you catch those earth worm arround your house where the
builder/pest control person layed tones of chemical to perform pest
and termite control. You can poison your fish to death.

Guess we should worry about those parasite more for ourselves before
worry for the fish, too.

 
 
 

Foods Koi Eat - What's good for them?

Post by Jack Konrat » Wed, 21 Aug 1996 04:00:00


Quote:

> In my ponds, the good looking Kois stay in the EPDM lined pond. They eat
> expensive Koi food, my plants and todpoles. They grow 3"~4" each year.
> In the clay pond, the not so good looking Kois and Comets dig into the
> clay, they eat earth worm, bird waste and whatever the nature feed them.
> Thye grow 5"~6" each year.

Paul, any evidence that the ugly fish in the clay pond LIVE LONGER?

Quote:
> Actually, the good looking fishes have higher chance being screwed by
> those artifitial food.

I'm interested to hear any evidence of this, Paul?

Quote:
> Guess we should worry about those parasite more for ourselves before
> worry for the fish, too.

Parasitic infections are trouble for both the fish and us, Paul. Virtually
every creature in the food chain brings with it attendant parasites. Just as
my catfish succumbed to intestinal parasites, so is man susceptible to
fish-born parasites like liver flukes, as an example, passed on through
ingestion of contaminated raw fish. In both cases, measures are available to
reduce the risks.

In nature, fish only have to survive long enough to reproduce.  In my pond,
I want my fish to last as long as possible, through as many reproductive
cycles as possible. Survival is more important than size in the case of my
pond inhabitants.

Actually, most of the fish common to ponding are herbivors. One of the
things that makes them so hardy in our ponds is the high availability of
suitable plant material in the form of algae, floating and rooted water
plants. A pond can be balanced such that it requires no addition of food.
While plants are the staple food source, most pond fish also enjoy the
occasional insect, worm, larva, etc., but by far, most of their energy input
comes from plants. Just as cooking our fish reduces the threat of ingesting
some weird parasite, I contend that supplementary feeding of pelletized Koi
food reduces the threat of the same thing happening to our fish. I invite
any evidence to the contrary.

Jack Konrath